Yes, QB play is MUCH more important than Defense

Over at Igglesblitz today, Tommy Lawlor mentioned that QB play and coaching are much more important than people realize, specifically citing the Packers defensive performance and record for 2010 and 2011.  Basically, the defense got A LOT worse while the record got better.

Here’s the link.

I figured I’d add some stats to the point to further illustrate it, because it’s both true and very important.  Unable to quantify coaching, we’ll focus on the QB.

Here are the charts for both Passer Rating vs. Wins and Yards Allowed vs. Wins.

Screen Shot 2013-02-13 at 4.37.00 PMScreen Shot 2013-02-13 at 4.41.59 PM

If you look at the slope of both lines (really the absolute value of each), its clear the above slope is much greater, hence a greater correlation.  Note: Tried my best to un-bias the effects of the different scales so it’d be visually clear.  Here are the correlation values:

Passer Rating:  .67

Yards Allowed: -.376

This is particularly relevant given the Eagles current situation, with QB uncertainty and a defense in need of serious upgrades (or significant improvement in current players).  In general, the play of Vick/Foles/Rookie? will be MUCH more important than the performance of the defense next year.

Another somewhat counterintuitive truth (at least regarding the magnitude of the difference in importance).  It also means the Eagles could use this draft, free agency, and scheme change to engineer a dramatic defensive improvement and still end up out of contention if the QB play isn’t good.



4 thoughts on “Yes, QB play is MUCH more important than Defense

  1. Pingback: Iggles Blitz » Blog Archive » Dennis Dixon Signs + More QB Talk

  2. Interesting and impressive.
    But yards allowed is not that accurate a measure of defense.
    Turnovers forced are important. Red zone efficiency as well
    The other thing is that the QB position is effectively fixed in many cases. That is, absent a great draft class and corresponding draft position, the range of available QBs is only so wide. There is no benefit in churning through second rate QBs. So in such cases you do the best you can, which may in fact mean upgrading your defense is the best you can do.

    • Good points. Regarding the last part, I didn’t mean to suggest the Eagles shouldn’t bother improving the defense. Doing so will absolutely improve the team’s chances at a title (obviously). Also, take a look at the draft posts and you’ll see I am pretty set against reaching for a need (i.e. QB this year).

      Yards allowed isn’t perfect, I agree with that as well. I’ll take a look at turnovers forced as well as a few other measures and post them too.

      I appreciate the feedback, thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s